*
An older Craftsman house with a neatly boarded window, framed by mature oak branches and deep green garden planting in soft afternoon light.

The Prices South Pasadena's Former Caltrans Houses Brought, Boarded Windows and All

On November 20, 2024, the South Pasadena City Council accepted a $1,451,000 offer for 216 Fairview Avenue. It was a three-bedroom, one-bath house with boarded windows. Caltrans had owned it for decades for a freeway that was never built. That bidder later bowed out. The Council took up the next-best offers, and the house went to a different bidder for $1,274,000, according to The South Pasadenan. The winning number dropped by $177,000 between the vote and the closing. That gap shows what decides these sales.

South Pasadena has now run two rounds of these sales. In the first round, the condition of the houses barely held prices down. The buyers who won were the ones who could close on a house sold as-is. The second round, listed this June, was set up to change who can make that kind of offer. For anyone weighing South Pasadena against Pasadena or San Marino, these sales say more about the city's older housing stock than a median price does.

Houses taken for a freeway that was never built

Caltrans bought about 450 homes across El Sereno, South Pasadena and Pasadena in the 1950s, '60s and '70s for a 6.3-mile extension of the 710. South Pasadena and environmental groups blocked the project in court during the 1970s and 1980s, as the Pasadena Star-News recounted this June. More than 60 of those properties were in South Pasadena.

The first five vacant houses came back to the market in 2024 by way of the city. South Pasadena paid Caltrans $165,700 for all five, The South Pasadenan reported. A February 2026 city staff report puts net proceeds from the December 2024 sales at $6,470,287.45, earmarked for affordable housing.

Five houses sold as-is, all above asking

The five houses went on the market in October 2024, on Fairview, Fremont and Meridian avenues, a few blocks from the city's main retail area. LAist described them the week of the open houses. Windows at 216 Fairview were covered with planks and metal bars. Pieces of the hallway ceiling were hanging down, and the wood floors were damaged. Even the listing team said "the whole house needs a lot of work." About 600 people had toured that one house by then. Thousands toured the five houses in all.

Here is how the asking prices from October 2024 compare with the prices that closed that December, as LAist reported in February 2025.

Property Asking, Oct. 2024 Sold, Dec. 2024 Over asking
726 Meridian Ave., three units nearly $1.25 million $1.72 million nearly $500,000
217 Fremont Ave., 3 bed / 3 bath nearly $1.2 million $1.45 million about $250,000
216 Fairview Ave., 3 bed / 1 bath $1.076 million $1.274 million about $200,000
225 Fremont Ave., 4 bed / 2 bath close to $1.2 million $1.377 million more than $175,000
1707 Meridian Ave., 2 bed $949,000 $1,007,000 $58,000

Look at the bottom row. When LAist visited, 1707 Meridian was the cheapest of the five and seemed to be in the best condition. It sold for about 6 percent over asking, the smallest premium in the group. The house a listing agent said "needs a lot of love" was 217 Fremont. It sold about 21 percent over asking. The top price went to 726 Meridian, a three-unit parcel that includes 1002 and 1008 Hope Street. The asking prices had already taken condition into account. The bids show that buyers discounted for condition much less than the asking prices did.

The nearby sales LAist cited support that reading. A duplex down the street on Diamond Avenue sold for $1.87 million the previous July, and a four-bedroom, two-bath house on Ramona Avenue sold for $1.57 million a few weeks before LAist's February 2025 report. Next to those, a three-unit corridor parcel needing years of repair at $1.72 million is priced mostly on its land and location. The work still to be done is a smaller share of the price than the boarded windows would suggest.

The offers that counted were the ones that closed

If condition didn't set the price, the ability to close did. The city's screening was built around the purchase price and the bottom-line net proceeds to the city, and the Council approved offers in closed session, The South Pasadenan reported in November 2024. An offer only helped the city's bottom line if it reached closing. That is why the $1,451,000 offer on Fairview ended up worth less than the $1,274,000 one that replaced it.

Buyers understood that before the bidding closed. The original $1,451,000 Fairview offer came through a firm that makes cash offers for clients, who then buy the property from it at the same price. The firm's representative told The South Pasadenan that this lets ordinary buyers compete with investors by dropping the financing contingency sellers dislike, and said this buyer planned to live in the house. Even that offer did not reach closing. Two other accepted bidders told the paper they had renovated older homes before and planned to move in with their families after the work was done.

The city came to the same conclusion. When officials looked back at the first round, they found that repair costs had made it hard for anyone other than investors to get financing, the South Pasadena Review reported.

A second group, listed with renovation loans on offer

On March 4, 2026, the City Council approved purchase agreements with Caltrans for another group of vacant properties. Marketing began June 9, according to the city's June 5 release. The release lists 1131 Columbia Street, 530 and 534 Orange Grove Avenue, 901 Bonita Drive, 1037 and 1039 Grevelia Street, 808 and 822 Valley View Road, and a property on Prospect Avenue. The Review reports that the city paid Caltrans about $1.5 million for the homes, the same price the state paid when it took them. City officials estimate the 12 properties approved in March could bring in about $10 million at today's prices. These houses were also vacant for years and need major rehabilitation, and they are being sold as-is.

The financing is what changed. For this group, the city and its listing team arranged with lenders to offer renovation loans to qualified borrowers. These loans are based on the estimated value of the house after it is restored, so they can cover the cost of the work. Mayor Sheila Rossi told the Review the goal was to "make sure we expanded the pool… making it open to more buyers and people who really want to make South Pasadena home versus more investors."

The first round makes it easy to see what that change does. In 2024, the top offer on Fairview was replaced by one that could close on a boarded-up house. A loan that funds both the purchase and the restoration lets more bidders clear that bar. With more bidders who can close, competition moves back to price. In the first round, even the house in the best condition sold above asking.

The Columbia House, and why it fits the pattern

The best-known house in the new group is the Columbia House at 1131 Columbia Street. It is a Craftsman designed by architect George Lawrence Stimson, on the corner of Columbia Street and Fremont Avenue. It dates to 1910 and is on the city's Inventory of Historic Resources. The Fremont houses that sold in the first round, at $1.45 million and $1.377 million, are on the same street.

A house on the historic inventory adds preservation review to the restoration plan. We covered how preservation review shapes repair timelines in South Pasadena in our post on historic home inspections running on two clocks. Both rounds of these sales point the same way. The buyers best placed for a house like this are the ones who have already priced the restoration and arranged how to pay for it.

The same applies to the whole Caltrans corridor. These houses on Fremont, Meridian, Columbia and Valley View are rare in a city with very few older homes, and sound or not, they sold near the prices of finished houses. If you are comparing South Pasadena with Pasadena or San Marino, a fixer here costs nearly as much as a finished house, so your restoration budget and plan matter as much as your offer price.

If you are weighing one of South Pasadena's former corridor houses, or any Craftsman that needs its next steward, Chelby Crawford can walk through the restoration math, the provenance and how to write an offer that will close. Request a private market consultation.

Work With Chelby

Chelby’s extensive expertise allows her to flawlessly navigate various economic markets and prepare her clients for absolutely every contingency. She is a true advocate, patiently and relentlessly honoring the needs of others while guarding their most important financial interest. She opens doors.